Question: Help!!  I would love to redo my fireplace mantel but I have no idea what to do about the fact that it is so high off the ground.  I would love to use travertine mosaic tiles or glass mosaic tiles but what can I do about the hearth/base of the fireplace being so high off the ground?  What material should I use to cover the wood to coordinate with mosaic tiles?  Please help!!  Any suggestions and advice would be greatly appreciated.  Thanks in advance for your help and inspiration.

that's one high fireplace! but there is hope!

Answer:

Wow!  That’s one high fireplace.  I’d bet that the reason for this went something like this in the mind of the person who decided it should be this high: I do not want to (or can’t) bend down or get on my knees every time I want to stoke the fire or add a log.

There is actually an economic reason for having the fireplace low to the ground. Since heat rises, the lower it is in the room, the more efficiently it heats the entire space.  But that’s another story.  This question is a straight-up: what to do now?

My first thought was probably much like your frustrated findings that there is no hope.  But the more I looked at it with a bit of imagination, the more I thought that there is hope.  I think the existing “stuff” around the firebox is making it hard to see the real meat of the issue.

If this was my house, no kidding, I would tear all that off of there and THEN stare at it to come up with a design solution.  I think the grate is especially challenging so if nothing else, remove the fire screen from in front of the fireplace while you think design.

I think something like a lower hearth, only 10″ above the floor or so, then a candle-shelf or some other ingenious bit of fireproof functionality in the space left between the mantle and the firebox.  I think I’ll try and make you a picture real quick…

Now I really did that quick… so please forgive the crooked lines etc.  I didn’t do any of them on purpose and I envision a pretty clean look on this so lots of sharp straight lines.

It is to scale though (traced from the picture you sent), so the proportions should be about right.  These ideas came to mind as I was doing this and they correspond to the numbers in the sketch…

1. The face of this little shelf has two really cool design possibilities. First, you could use it as a place to feature some really neat art tiles, such as hand blown glass tiles or some really cool fired ceramics.  Second idea was to make this shelf a little taller, dig out some wall space behind, and create a place for wood here.  But that would be more work than the first idea.

2. I think the top of this is perfect for candles, and far enough away from the fireplace to keep them from melting.  (most people use the candles in the summer and the real fire in the winter and take away the candles.  You could display some cool vessels of some sort here.  If going with glass tiles, this is more opportunity for some neat glass objects.

3.  The firebox is big and I don’t know what the inside looks like.  I think a new set of glass doors would be needed, with no metal if possible.  Just clear glass if the inside of the firebox looks good.

4. If you go with the clean sleek look, and use glass tiles on the fronts of everything then I think a nice clean wood mantle without any frill would work, maybe a dark color stain, or paint.

5. For some reason, and I didn’t have time to put this all together, the idea of a big slate hearth surface came to mind.  I’d have to work on balancing the look of slate with the glass, and the colors would all have to work, but some sort of honed stone might look good on both hearth shelf surfaces.

Just thoughts.  Hope they help.

Tim

You can submit a question on a new topic here or if you have a question directly related to this answer, you can ask that in the comments below.

{ 1 comment }

Can I Add a Second Floor Completely Above and Independent of my Existing Home?

September 14, 2011

Question: Tim, Coming at you from NSW Australia. Thanks for your very informative article on your Second Story ” Stilt Home” concept of keeping the actual structure below intact. My wife thought i was l losing my mind. We need to expand our one storey rancher. As you may be able to determine from the [...]

Read the full article →

Touch Kitchen Faucet? Foot Pedal Controls?

June 9, 2011

Question: I am thinking of how useful a foot pedal might be at my kitchen sink.  Not even sure that is the proper name.  Cost might be prohibitive but have no idea yet.  What are your thoughts?  Thanks, Tim, for sharing your knowledge and expertise with all your followers! Answer: You’re welcome and thank you [...]

Read the full article →

Is a in ground sprinkler system worth it?

June 8, 2011

Question: Is a in ground sprinkler system worth it? I am installing new sod and have the option to put in a new sprinkler system which will cost quite a bit of money but I am curious do you think they are worth it? Answer: The main factor in this is the size of your [...]

Read the full article →

Is it ok to mix chrome and satin or brushed nickel? Does Moen or Delta nickel tarnish?

June 8, 2011

Question: We are replacing our laminate bathroom countertop with granite.This involves removing the mirror and replacing the faucet and sink-all of which are 20 yrs old. We have a chrome light fixture that I do not need to replace. We were thinking of replacing the chrome faucet and knobs with satin nickel. Now I am [...]

Read the full article →

What’s a good height for beadboard, if any?

June 8, 2011

Question: Remember that time you were going to go into beadboard more extensively? You mention it in “RG’s Complete Guide To Wood Paneling – Part 5 – Inspiring Beadboard.”  That would be awesome if you finished that.  But my question is, if I don’t want to do beadboard 3/4 of the way up (I want [...]

Read the full article →

Tips on how to paint a newly installed unfinished pine wood floor? Would like a whitewash look.

March 20, 2011

This could be a trick question!  The reason is that a “whitewash look” as you mentioned you would like, is a description that’s a little bit in the eyes of the beholder.  The two looks that come to my mind when you mention “whitewashed” are: 1. The pool table I bought in 1992 with the [...]

Read the full article →

How to determine whether I am getting a fair price for a garage rebuild?

March 4, 2011

Fair price is a tough thing to pin down.  What’s fair to you might not be fair to someone else because it depends on your criteria.  If you consider getting “the best” tradesmen to do your work important and want a contractor who does more than meet the minimum licensing requirements then you probably would [...]

Read the full article →

Wood floor coming up or buckling due to moisture in slab or improper installation.

March 3, 2011

Have a wood floor that started to come up in some places (moisture).  Slab was not tested prior to putting down 3/8″ wood with glue + moisture barrier.  Knowing now we would have put down tile.  We want to repair and enjoy the floor for now.  What is the best way to repair (for now) [...]

Read the full article →

If painting banister/steps black – should I use paint or black lacquer?

February 27, 2011

Lacquer finishes generally require special spray equipment, ventilation, surface preparation, and a good bit of experience, so they usually aren’t great for residential remodeling, and even less commonly used in DIY finishing. But that’s not such a bad thing because if it’s done right, most paints will work on floor surfaces, steps included.  I assume [...]

Read the full article →